Bitcoin Cash upgrade that would mandate all newly minted blocks donate 8% to development is threatening to drive a hard fork
Bitcoin ABC, the dominant implementation of Bitcoin Cash (BCH), announced a controversial new upgrade that BCH proponents had to implement before November 15 to facilitate changes to delivery. The core formula of crypto assets.
Amuary Sechet: Upgrade or Bitcoin Cash Is Destined for Irrelevance
Top developer Amaury Sechet said part of the reason for the new upgrade is to provide a significant source of development capital to allow Bitcoin Cash to compete with Bitcoin and Ethereum.
“In comparison, Bitcoin Cash is lacking in funding and the result is a poorly maintained infrastructure, highly dependent on the work of other teams such as Bitcoin Core’s, as well as poor developer tools.”
The update will introduce a new difficulty adjustment algorithm dubbed ASERT in response to drawn-out block times, alongside a controversial feature that will reject all newly mined blocks that do not divert 8% of rewards to a wallet designated to funding ongoing development to the ABC protocol — dubbed the Coinbase rule.
Sechet predicts that without the Coinbase rule, BCH’s future is a slow drift into irrelevance but said the split in the community ran much deeper than this one issue. While some are attributing the BCH tensions to the Coinbase rule, not even a month ago it was about difficulty adjustment … These details are not very relevant.
“A split happens first at the community level, and then reasons are found to perpetuate it. I do not think there is anything that can be done to reunite the community at this point in time.”
Bitcoin ABC said the coinbase rule would allow more technical talent to be hired to maintain and develop the network predicting this will result in the removal of transaction chain bottlenecks to speed up BCH transfers further.
The coinbase rule appears set to become the catalyst for a hard fork in November — with some supporters of the alternative BCH implementation Bitcoin Cash Node (BCHN) calling for the resignation of Sechet.
Bitcoin Cash’s most high-profile proponent Roger Ver has expressed opposition to the coinbase rule — likening the upgrade on Reddit to a change that will alter BCH to more closely resemble Dash.
“I like Dash, but I DON’T think BCH should be altered to more closely resemble DASH. I wish those in the BCH community who want to change BCH to be more like DASH would just sell their BCH for DASH.”
Calls for Sechet’s resignation
In a blog post calling for Sechet’s resignation, BCHN supporter Nilac The Grim described the much-dreaded IFP Coinbase Rule as the primary source of contention among the BCH camps, asserting that the alternative BCH implementations – Bitcoin Unlimited, bchd, Flower, Bitcoin Verde, and K-nuth – are all opposed to its introduction.
Nilac said that recent fundraising has demonstrated that the community loves to pay its dev project, emphasizing that there is no problem funding infrastructure.
Nilac predicted that Bitcoin Cash would avoid a November hard fork despite the tensions:
“We are in communication with mining pools in China and pretty clear they are also against this unilateral modification to the coinbase reward.”
Sechet is unsure if BCH will see a fork in November, emphasizing that BCHN will accept blocks coming from ABC but not the other way around.
“This means that there will be a fork if BCHN has more hash than ABC, but not the other way around.”
However, in the event of a fork, Sechet warned that the BCHN chain would be wiped out should the BCH chain become longer than the BCHN chain after the chain split.
“I don’t think any exchange in their right mind will list an asset that can be wiped out, so they might be forced to execute an emergency hard fork that ensures the chain’s survival.”
- Top Analyst: Bitcoin Cash Could Be On Its Way To Fall Under $100
- Following A 39% Price Surge At The End Of July, At Least 10 Bitcoin Cash Whales Have Left The Network